First Mate's Menu

Sitting down to write about First Mate’s’s menu feels like reliving a fun afternoon by Erie’s shoreline. The menu mixes classic comfort eats with local flair, and you can tell each dish is meant to satisfy both belly and soul. Start with a refreshing lemonade to wash away the summer heat before diving into their famed pulled pork poutine - a hearty bowl where smoky pork meets rich gravy and cheese curds for a seriously indulgent bite. If seafood is calling you, the perch and fries (3 pieces fish) and 3‑piece fish and chips both deliver crispy, golden batter and flaky lake‑fresh fish that pair perfectly with the house‑cut fries, while the perch sandwich and fries gives you the same great taste between buns for a handheld treat.

Beyond the classics, there’s a playful side to the menu with spicy poutine adding a kick to a beloved comfort food and pizza wraps offering a fun twist that keeps things interesting. Sandwich lovers won’t be disappointed either, with a pulled pork sandwich and poutine combo that doubles down on flavor and value. Throughout the meal, the portions stay generous and the vibe remains laid‑back and welcoming, making every visit feel like a shared meal with friends. If you’re wrapping up your review, this varied lineup - from fries and fish to wraps and poutines - shows First Mate’s really knows how to hit the comfort food sweet spot, keeping locals and visitors coming back for more.